Where to Buy Headlights Online: 7 Retailers Compared
There are a lot of places to buy headlights online. Too many, honestly. Here's a straight comparison of the seven biggest retailers so you can skip the guesswork and just pick one.
Quick Comparison
Here's the short version. Every retailer has trade-offs. The best pick depends on what matters most to you: price, speed, or selection.
RockAuto
Pros: Lowest prices, huge catalog, cheap shipping options
Cons: No-frills website, no phone support, restocking fees on returns
AutoZone
Pros: Same-day in-store pickup, easy returns, solid online selection
Cons: Higher prices than online-only retailers, fewer aftermarket brands
Advance Auto Parts
Pros: Frequent online coupon codes, in-store pickup, good brand selection
Cons: Prices a bit higher without coupons, website can be clunky
PartsGeek
Pros: Aggressive pricing, wide selection, good search filters
Cons: Return process can be a hassle, slower shipping on some items
eBay Motors
Pros: Best for rare and older vehicles, buyer protection, huge seller network
Cons: Quality varies by seller, need to check ratings carefully
JEGS
Pros: Great for performance and upgraded headlights, knowledgeable support
Cons: Smaller selection for standard replacements, higher prices on basics
Summit Racing
Pros: Performance-focused, excellent customer service, fast shipping
Cons: Limited stock for everyday replacement parts, pricier than discount sites
Retailer Breakdown
RockAuto
RockAuto is the go-to for budget-conscious buyers. Their website looks like it hasn't been updated since 2005, but that's part of the charm. Low overhead means low prices. They carry a massive catalog of headlight assemblies from dozens of brands.
Shipping is cheap, especially if you're not in a rush. The downside? No phone support and returns come with restocking fees on certain items. If you know exactly what you need, RockAuto is hard to beat on price.
AutoZone
AutoZone's biggest advantage is same-day pickup. Order online, grab it at your local store an hour later. Their online selection is decent, and returns are painless since you can just walk into any location.
Prices are a bit higher than online-only retailers. You're paying for the convenience of brick-and-mortar backup. If your headlight is out and you need it today, AutoZone is a solid call.
Advance Auto Parts
Similar to AutoZone in a lot of ways. In-store pickup, wide availability, easy returns. Where Advance pulls ahead is with coupon codes. They almost always have some kind of online discount running.
Before you buy, do a quick search for "Advance Auto promo code." You'll almost certainly find 15 to 25% off. That can close the gap with cheaper online-only stores.
PartsGeek
PartsGeek has aggressive pricing and a wide selection. Their search filters make it easy to narrow down by year, make, model, and trim. Prices are competitive with RockAuto on a lot of parts.
The catch? Returns can be tricky. Read the return policy before ordering. Some items have short return windows or require you to pay return shipping. Know the policy upfront and you'll be fine.
eBay Motors
If you're looking for headlights for an older or rare vehicle, eBay Motors is your best bet. The seller network is massive, and you'll find parts that are long discontinued elsewhere.
Always check seller ratings and read recent reviews. Stick with sellers who have 98% or higher positive feedback and a solid track record with auto parts. eBay's buyer protection is good, but avoiding problems is better than filing claims.
JEGS
JEGS is more of a performance parts retailer. If you're looking for upgraded or specialty headlights (think projector retrofits or LED conversions), they're worth checking.
For basic replacement headlights on a daily driver, JEGS probably isn't your first stop. But if you're building something or want better-than-stock lighting, their selection and support are excellent.
Summit Racing
Summit is similar to JEGS in focus. Performance builds, custom projects, upgraded lighting. Their customer service is consistently rated highly, and shipping is fast.
Like JEGS, they're not the cheapest option for a basic stock replacement. But for performance headlights and specialty fitments, Summit is a trusted name.
How to Compare for Your Vehicle
The easiest way to compare prices is to check two or three retailers with your exact vehicle info. Here's what to do:
- Enter your year, make, and model. Every retailer has a vehicle selector. Use it. Don't just search by part name.
- Check fitment notes. Some vehicles have multiple headlight options depending on trim level or production date. Make sure the listing matches your exact setup.
- Compare total cost. Add shipping to the price. A cheaper headlight with $20 shipping might cost more than a slightly pricier one with free shipping.
- Read reviews for your vehicle. Generic product reviews are fine, but reviews from someone with the same car tell you way more about fit and quality.
Ready to compare prices?
Enter your vehicle and we'll show you headlight options across multiple retailers. One search, all the results.
Find Your HeadlightGet Deal Alerts
We'll let you know about deals and new options for your vehicle.